Pilot Debrief

BEECH C 99 near Spanish Fork, UT — 2016-08-02

Final reportWPR16LA155
Sign in to save
Date
2016-08-02
Location
Spanish Fork, UT, USA
Aircraft
BEECH C 99
Registration
N234AV
Category
Airplane
Highest injury
None
Fatalities
0
Phase of flight
Cruise

Probable cause

An in-flight collision with power lines.

NTSB narrative

The commercial pilot of the scheduled cargo flight reported that, during cruise flight about 8,000 ft indicated altitude, he heard a small impact noise and believed that the airplane was struck by a bird. There was no loss of directional control, change in control configuration, or impact shudder. He continued the flight and subsequently landed without further incident. After exiting the airplane, the pilot noticed that about 12 inches of the top of the vertical stabilizer was missing, and that there was substantial damage to the rudder. The separated top of the vertical stabilizer section was not recovered. The fracture surface of the upper section of the remaining vertical stabilizer was in a nearly horizontal plane. The skin was deformed adjacent to the fracture into curled rolls turning downward and aft. Some areas were crushed, consistent with the vertical stabilizer moving forward relative to another object. Sliding contact marks were observed at the leading edges, vertical spars, and deformed faces of the skin panel adjacent to the fracture. No evidence of any biological or manufactured foreign material transfer was observed associated with any of the fracture surfaces either visually or under optical magnification. Closer examination identified deposits of particles consistent with aluminum alloy 2024 and similar metallic element peaks. Other particles had spectra consistent with a low alloy steel, stainless steel, brass, and a nickel-base alloy with iron and chromium. The curling deformation to the skin and the deformation through the airplane structure was consistent with contact with a stationary object, such as a suspended cable. Given the diameter of the impact deformation and the materials found, it is likely that the airplane impacted overhead power transmission lines during a portion of the flight that was conducted at an altitude much lower than reported.

Analysis

Primary failure mode
Other
First missed decision gate
Pilot could have altered course to avoid potential bird strike.

NTSB coding

Evidence available

  • Photos
  • 3 docket documents
View NTSB final reportView NTSB docket

Docket documents3

Related mishaps